Great Midwest Agency Group, Inc.

The core difference between an insurance broker and a captive agent lies in whom they represent and, consequently, the range of options they can offer you.

 

Insurance Broker:

• Represents You (the client): A broker acts as an independent intermediary, working on your behalf to find the best insurance solutions. They are not tied to any single insurance company.

​

• Wide Range of Options: Brokers have access to policies from multiple insurance companies. This allows them to shop around, compare quotes, and find a policy that best fits your specific needs and budget.

​

• Unbiased Advice: Because they work with various carriers, brokers are incentivized to provide unbiased advice, focusing on your best interests rather than promoting a specific company's products.

​

• Customized Solutions: They can often craft insurance packages tailored to your unique requirements, even if it means combining policies from different insurers.

​

• Claims Advocacy: If you need to file a claim, a broker can act as your advocate, guiding you through the process and helping to ensure fair treatment from the insurance company.

 

Captive Agent:

• Represents One Insurance Company: A captive agent works exclusively for a single insurance company (e.g., State Farm, Farmers, Allstate). They are essentially an employee or contracted representative of that specific insurer.

​

• Limited Product Range: They can only offer you insurance policies and products from the company they represent. Their selection is confined to what that one carrier offers.

​

• Company-Oriented: While they aim to help clients, their primary allegiance and incentives are with their parent company.

​

• In-depth Product Knowledge: Captive agents often have deep expertise in the products and services offered by their specific company.

​

• Brand Recognition and Support: They benefit from the marketing and brand recognition of the large insurance company they work for, which can instill trust in clients.

​

• Claims Assistance: They can assist with claims processing, acting as a direct intermediary between you and their company.

​

Choosing between the two depends on your preferences. If you want a wide array of options, unbiased advice, and expert knowledge of all different insurance company products, a broker is generally a good choice.